Research & TrendsMPs criticise BT’s lack of transparency over rural broadband contracts

MPs criticise BT’s lack of transparency over rural broadband contracts

BT has been the subject of harsh criticism over its “insistence on non-disclosure agreements” in rural broadband contracts.

BT has been the subject of harsh criticism over its “insistence on non-disclosure agreements” in rural broadband contracts.

The Public Accounts Select Committee (PAC) said BT had won all 44 contracts with local authorities to provide broadband and the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) has “allowed poor cost transparency and lack of detailed broadband rollout plans to create conditions whereby alternative suppliers may be crowded out”.

Margaret Hodge, committee chairman and Labour MP, said:“BT’s monopoly position should have been a red flag for the department. But we see the lack of transparency on costs and BT’s insistence on non-disclosure agreements as symptomatic of BT exploiting its monopoly position to the detriment of the taxpayer, local authorities and those seeking to access high speed broadband in rural areas.”

More than £490m in grant funding to 44 local authorities and groups of authorities is being provided under the programme by DMCS by 2015 to subsidise authorities to procure broadband services.

Hodge added: “The department should collect, analyse and publish data on deployment costs in the current programme, to inform its consideration of bids from suppliers under the next round of funding. And before that next round of funding is released, the department should work with local authorities to ensure there is real competition and value for money.

“If we don’t hear that the department is making significant progress on our recommendations we will require a further hearing to find out why it is not improving its approach to protecting public funds.”

A BT spokesman said: “We respect the role of the committee but we feel their criticism of BT is inaccurate and unjustified.

“BT was the only company willing to accept the challenging terms on offer and make a significant investment in rural areas. This was at a time when others walked away when they realised easy pickings weren’t to be had. Claims that BT is a monopoly are simply inaccurate given more than 100 ISPs are offering fibre across BT’s open network.”

Communications Minister Ed Vaizey said: “As we approach the milestone of connecting 500,000 homes under our programme, and overtake Germany in terms of broadband connectivity, people would be forgiven for thinking this latest salvo has missed the point.” 

Related Articles

Seven digital government trends to look out for in 2018

Adult Social Care Seven digital government trends to look out for in 2018

8m Austin Clark
UK falling behind in government digitisation according to report

Data Insight UK falling behind in government digitisation according to report

11m Austin Clark
Desire to deliver better customer service is driving the next phase of digital transformation

Digital Transformation & Change Desire to deliver better customer service is driving the next phase of digital transformation

1y Austin Clark
Could immersive collaboration tools optimise public sector work?

Digital Transformation & Change Could immersive collaboration tools optimise public sector work?

1y Austin Clark
Top 10 strategic technologies for Government

Digital Transformation & Change Top 10 strategic technologies for Government

1y Austin Clark
Digital skills and sharing key to public service transformation, survey finds

Digital Skills Digital skills and sharing key to public service transformation, survey finds

1y Austin Clark
UK public sector faces major DNS threat and rising cost of security breaches, survey finds

Cyber Security UK public sector faces major DNS threat and rising cost of security breaches, survey finds

1y Austin Clark
Five reasons cyberattacks succeed

Cyber Security Five reasons cyberattacks succeed

1y Austin Clark